CA Governor Newsom Signs Emergency Bill Allowing Restaurants to Keep Service Fees, With a Catch

By: Sam Watanuki | Last updated: Jul 17, 2024

Late Saturday night, California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed emergency legislation. This law allows restaurants to keep surcharges in place, provided they clearly disclose the additional charges.

The new legislation amends a 2023 law aimed at eliminating “junk fees.”

Background of the 2023 Law

The 2023 legislation was introduced to tackle “junk fees” that many businesses added to customer bills.

Advertisement
Lawyer fills out paperwork on a desk with a judges gavel beside him

Source: Freepik

These fees often appeared as surprises, leading to consumer frustration. Restaurants were initially included in this law.

Making Money on Hidden Fees

Companies often add extra fees when booking a hotel room or purchasing tickets for an upcoming event. Often, these extra fees are normally called “service fees” or other broad labels that make consumers scratch their heads.

Advertisement
A close-up of many different American dollar bills.

Source: Blogging Guide/Unsplash

However, Newsom is attempting to stop these hidden fees by forcing some businesses to display the charges on menus or advertisements.

A Change for the Better

Legal analyst Wendy Patrick told CBS 8 what consumers can expect with the new laws going into effect. “This new law is going to require restaurants to showcase the additional fees somewhere that is conspicuous,” she said. “In other words, no fine print.”

Advertisement
Person Pouring Wine on Clear Wine Glass

Source: Terje Sollie/Pexels

The restaurant will provide customers with the prices of menu items and any surcharges before charging them for the meal.

The Push for Transparency 

This new bill will allow restaurants to disclose any additional fees, such as automatic service charges for restaurants that use a tipless model, “clearly and conspicuously” on menus or “other displays,” as is current practice for many food businesses.

Advertisement
A man is pictured looking into his wallet to find it empty

Source: Freepik

“The principle behind this bill is simple: the final purchase price for a good or service shouldn’t be a mystery for California consumers,” Sen. Dodd said.

The Role of Senator Bill Dodd

Senator Bill Dodd of Napa was instrumental in the latest amendment.

Advertisement
A photograph of a lawyer meeting with a client

Source: Freepik

He emphasized the importance of transparency, stating, “We made it clear they can’t just change it without putting it in clear and concise type on the menu on every single page.”

Advertisement

No More Surprises

“Restaurant customers shouldn’t be surprised when they get their checks by a boatload of extra charges they’re not expecting,” said Sen. Bill Dodd, who also co-wrote the junk fees law, to the SF Chronicle.

Advertisement
Man is surprised to hear about what unfolded during the recent F1 Grand Prix of Monaco

Source: Mark Thompson/Getty Images

“Many restaurants are upfront with their business practices but too many aren’t, necessitating action. This proposal will level the playing field for all restaurants and address confusion and disagreement about what is permissible under state law.”

Advertisement

Why This Change Is Needed for Consumers

“Businesses use hidden fees or junk fees to pitch an artificially low headline price to attract a customer before revealing additional charges,” Eleanor Blume, California’s assistant attorney general, said to CBS News.

Advertisement
A group of men and women sat around a table eating food. There is food and wine on the table.

Alex Haney/Unsplash

“Hidden fees are bad for consumers and bad for competition,” she adds.

Advertisement

People Deserve to Know the Truth

While many businesses and restaurant owners are reading the change, which will ban separate surcharges that restaurateurs increasingly rely on to pay higher wages to staff, consumers celebrate the law.

Advertisement
Man in Pink Dress Shirt looking up at the sky

Source: Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

“People deserve to know the true price of products upfront so that they can do good comparison shopping and so that there’s just good competition in the marketplace,” Jenn Engstrom, state director for the California Public Interest Research Group, a Los Angeles-based nonprofit, told NPR.

Advertisement

The Fear of Uncertainty for Consumers

“It feels all over the place” right now, Erin Witte, the director of consumer protection for the Consumer Federation of America, tells NPR. “You’re thinking about late fees and increased interest and things like that. So it’s not just annoying, it’s harmful for many folks.”

Advertisement
A woman looks over her bills, clearly stressed

Source: Freepik

With inflation high and the cost of food increasing, people are uncertain about the cost of their diners making it harder to budget.

Advertisement

The Threat to Restaurants

Restaurant owners say that changes will bring higher prices and sticker shock to consumers, which could then raise the psychological hurdles in customer’s dining habits.

Advertisement
Person Holding Pastry Dishes on White Ceramic Plates

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

This change could hurt restaurants that are already struggling to recover from the devastating blows of the COVID-19 pandemic and the increasing inflation.

Advertisement

California Restaurant Association's Opposition

The California Restaurant Association (CRA) opposed the initial law, arguing it shouldn’t apply to restaurants.

Advertisement
Gavin Newsome pictured standing during a speech

Source: Getty Images

The CRA claimed that menu items do not qualify as “goods” or “services” under California’s civil code.

Advertisement

Support for Restaurants

“This will enable restaurants to continue to support increased pay equity and to make contributions to worker health care and other employee benefits,” Matthew Sutton, the restaurant association’s senior vice president of government affairs and public policy​, said in a news release.

Advertisement
Shallow Focus Photo of Woman Smiling While Holding Pen and Paper

Source: Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

“And, importantly, consumers will remain empowered to make informed choices about where they choose to dine out.”

Advertisement

Conditions for Keeping Surcharges

While restaurants can keep surcharges, they must ensure that these are clearly disclosed. This requirement aims to prevent any surprises for customers when they receive their bill.

Advertisement
Person Sitting in Front of Tacos on Plate

Source: Chitokan C./Pexels

Full compliance is expected within a year.

Advertisement

Restaurants are Vital to the State

“Restaurants are vital to the fabric of life in California, and they should be able to cover costs as long as they do so transparently,” Sen. Scott Wiener said in the news release.

Advertisement
Bartender Holding a Cocktail

Source: Antoni Shkraba/Pexels

“SB1524 clarifies portions of the law that pose a serious threat to restaurants. The bill strikes the right balance between supporting restaurants and delivering transparency for consumers, and I’m proud to support it.”

Advertisement

Finding a Better Deal

Wiener spoke to a group of about 65 restaurant owners from across the state during a virtual town hall meeting on the surcharges ban, hosted by San Francisco restaurant consulting group New Deal Hospitality, to talk about a possible solution.

Advertisement
Two Person in Long-sleeved Shirt Shakehand

Source: Cytonn Photography/Pexels

After the meeting, New Deal Hospitality CEO Bevan Bunch said: “Most of our clients are moving forward with preparing for the worst and hoping for the best.”

Advertisement

Consumer Reactions to the Amendment

Many consumers are supportive of the change, appreciating the transparency it brings.

Advertisement
Woman Eating Bruschetta

Source: Adrienn/Pexels

Jarrett Powers from San Jose mentioned, “I don’t think it’s a bad thing it’s still there because it’s going to workers or at least it should be going toward workers.”

Advertisement

One-Year Compliance Period

Restaurants have one year to comply with the new disclosure rules.

Advertisement
Person Holding Pastry Dishes on White Ceramic Plates

Source: Pixabay/Pexels

This period allows establishments to update their menus and meet the legal requirements, ensuring transparency for all patrons.

Advertisement

The Guidelines of the Law

If a business violates this new mandate, the law allows a consumer to seek “actual damages of at least $1,000.” The guidelines won’t focus initial enforcement efforts on “fees that are paid directly and entirely by a restaurant to its workers, such as an automatic gratuity.”

Advertisement
A large group of people sat around a table eating and drinking.

Source: Priscilla Du Preez/Unsplash

“However, businesses may be liable in private actions,” the guidelines add.

Advertisement

Impact on Restaurant Operations

For restaurants, this amendment provides operational flexibility. They can continue to charge surcharges but must ensure these fees are clearly communicated.

Advertisement
Cooking of Tacos on a Large Pan

Source: Los Muertos Crew/Pexels

This balance aims to protect consumers while supporting businesses.

Advertisement

Potential Benefits for Workers

Some consumers believe that these surcharges benefit restaurant workers.

Advertisement
Cooked Food On Blue Plate

Source: Chitokan C./Pexels

There is an expectation that the additional charges support fair wages and better working conditions for staff.

Advertisement

Ensuring Legal Compliance

Legal compliance is crucial for restaurants to avoid penalties.

Advertisement
A lawyer is pictured at his desk

Source: Freepik

Clear communication on menus is mandated to adhere to the new law, preventing any misinterpretation by customers.

Advertisement

Broader Implications for Consumer Protection

This legislation reflects a broader trend towards consumer protection and transparency.

Advertisement
Man in Brown Dress Shirt Standing Beside Woman in Red Dress

Source: cottonbro studio/Pexels

By regulating how additional charges are disclosed, it aims to build trust between businesses and consumers.

Advertisement

Future Outlook

Governor Newsom’s signing of the emergency bill marks a significant shift in the state’s approach to regulating service fees.

Advertisement
Gavin Newsom standing behind a wooden lectern. The U.S. and California flags are behind him.

Source: Office of the Governor of California/Wikimedia Commons

As restaurants adapt to these changes, the emphasis remains on clear communication and transparency, ultimately benefiting both businesses and consumers.

Advertisement